Palfrey on road to recovery

    Top-Lead

    Swimmer Penny Palfrey was released from hospital Tuesday morning after being hospitalised for a day and a half to recuperate from her epic 40 hour and 41 minute swim from Little Cayman to Grand Cayman. 

    Her husband Chris Palfrey, who was on the support crew that accompanied her during the swim, said on Monday night that she was recovering well and he expected her to be released Tuesday. 

    “The swelling is already going down and she’s starting to look like herself,” Mr. Palfrey said Monday evening. 

    When Ms Palfrey came ashore at 10.07pm Sunday, she was almost unrecognisable, with swollen lips and a discoloured face. She suffered sunburn and dehydration during her swim. On Monday, she was still having difficulty speaking as her mouth and tongue remained swollen from salt water. 

    Sharks 

    During her epic swim, three Oceanic white tip sharks that got close to her were killed. The shark killings have drawn strong criticism from the shark conservation community. 

    Mr. Palfrey said his wife and her team had come to Cayman to do a swim and there had been 
no intention to kill sharks. 

    “It was not in any of our plans for that to happen. I was not aware it was going to happen until after the event. Our goal was to do a swim. It was not to do anything to the environment,” he said. 

    Kayaker Richard Clifford, to whom one of the 
sharks came within a few feet, said of those moments when the sharks were closing in, “Penny was the endangered species out there.” He added: “No one went out there with the intention to harm anything.” 

    Fisherman Charles Ebanks
 told the crew that the sharks were very aggressive and would have continued to threaten the swimmer.  

    Director of the Department of Environment Gina Ebanks-Petrie said: “Given the importance of sharks as a top-level predator in the marine environment, the DoE would have preferred to have seen this incident handled differently… I don’t have any specifics on the level of actual threat or risk that Penny faced from those sharks.” 

    Local sealife conservationist Guy Harvey said he thought the fact that the sharks were killed was a shame and excessive, but acknowledged that they were “a real threat”. 

    “People had to anticipate that fact that the Oceanic white tip shark are an integral part of the oceanic environment there. They should have thought about that,” he said. He said the white tips usually bump up against a swimmer again and again “to test and see and then take a bite”. 

    The swimmer had told her team that she had been bumped in the dark several times as she swam through Saturday night.  

    A kayak and inflatable power boat beside her each carried a Shark Shield that emits electrical pulses to repel sharks, but it appeared at least one of the sharks got closer than the 26 feet of protection it was meant to provide. 

    Oceanic white tip sharks are listed as vulnerable worldwide in the International Union for Conservation of Nature’s list of threatened species, and are listed as critically endangered in the northwest and west central Atlantic. 

    Record  

    Ms Palfrey broke the existing world record of 63 miles for a solo ocean unassisted swim. Unassisted is defined as without a wetsuit or shark cage. 

    The team had estimated that her swim would take between 30 and 40 hours, with some predicting it would take a little over 32 hours.  

    In the end, she swam eight hours beyond that hoped-for time. The swimmer, whose swim lasted the equivalent of an average working week, averaged a pace of 2.3 miles per hour for the first one third of her swim, but her speed fell as the swim continued as she was hit by currents and high ocean swells. 

    “Five to 10 miles out [from the finish], she hit a wicked current, right smack into her. I would not have guessed, she could have swum though that.  

    Her arm strokes were weak, she was just slicing through the water,” said Steven Munatones, one of her support crew after 
the swim. 

    TopStory

    Penny Palfrey powers through the water watched by kayaker Jeff Kozlovich
    NORMA CONNOLLY

    5 COMMENTS

    1. Penny showed fortitude and inner strength to accomplish this feat. Congratulations to you Penny. I do not know anyone who has the determination and will to accomplish such a milestone. It is unfortunate that sea creatures possibly threatened Penny’s life and safety. Her life and safety were paramount and all caution and actions should be taken to protect her. Congratulations Again.

    2. Fantastic!! Another proud human endeavour. Personal gain but at what cost? Who cares, I got my record. Killing 3 white tip sharks. Penny was the endangered species out there…really..6 billion humans and counting. Your record will probably be remembered but 3 majestic animals are gone from this planet.

    3. My first question to everyone on this post is: How many hours/ encounters have you personally had with Oceanic White Tip sharks in open ocean? I personally beleive that conservation is of the utmost importance. I have been a recreational angler for many years and unfortunately I have caught white tips in the past (unintentionally while tuna fishing). One of which was gut hooked and we were unable to safely release it. When we gutted the shark it had many objects from bits of garbage to even a plastic toy doll. These sharks are the scavengers of the ocean, they are not the most aggressive shark but they are extremely curious and will bite just about anything that comes across its path. The sharks may not have intended to eat Penny, but for anyone to say that there is 100% no way one of those sharks would have bitten her is negligent. I understand that it is very unfortunate for the sharks to be killed and yes, Penny knew the dangers/risks, but to me, in the end a human life is more important. Sharks are Apex predators, killing/eating is all they do. These sharks are also extremely persistent, there is very little other than getting out of the water that Penny could have done to get these sharks to leave her alone. I have had experiences when we have been trying to catch other fish and a White Tip has taken the hook, bitten through the line (mono, so not intended for catching sharks) and kept coming back trying to take other baits. Any other fish or shark that I have encountered will disappear after feeling a hook and getting off….not these sharks. Again I feel that it is very unfortunate that these sharks were killed, but make no mistake, Penny was in real danger with these sharks around. If she had any chance to complete this swim then the sharks needed to be removed and short of dragging them several miles away (which was probably not feasible) I feel that the crew acted in a way that saved her life. I know that your next argument will be that she should not be there in the first place, but to say that the sharks would not touch her lacks a certain degree of real knowledge of the situation and common sense.

    4. so the anwers would have been for her to get out of the water (the sharks environment) and continue on later then, easy. NOT KILL THE SHARKS

    Comments are closed.