Premier lashes out against media, FOI


Premier McKeeva Bush lashed out
against elements of the media and the Freedom of Information Law during a press
conference last Thursday and threatened to impose a six-figure licence fee on
media outlets.

Responding to an FOI request
submitted by Cayman News Service about his travel since last year, Mr. Bush
said answering the question had taken civil servants “many hours to compile.”

“The information was not readily
available and required the involvement of different ministries and portfolios,”
he said.

Mr. Bush said he had no problem
with transparency and accountability.

“But the truth is, the FOI Law,
while purporting to ensure transparency and accountability, costs the country a
lot, especially as it ties up civil servants who are required to work under
this law responding to requests which can literally come from Mickey Mouse,” he
said. “So, instead of doing business and helping turn this economy around,
people have to be writing back to Mr. Mickey Mouse. And they call this progress.
If Mr. Mickey Mouse sends in a request, by law civil servants must answer.

“Clearly, this cannot be what was
intended by this law.”

Mr. Bush said the FOI request from
Cayman News Service requested to know which countries he had visited as leader
of government business and premier; the dates he had visited the countries; the
purpose of the visits; and who accompanied him on each trip.

“Tell me what good is this question?
Everyone knows that I have to travel.”

Mr. Bush said he answered the
question publicly so that all could hear his answer, and not “spin on CNS.”

He said that in the next budget,
which is expected by the end of the month, “those businesses, blogs and such,
are going to have to pay a good, good fee,” which he said would be more than
$100,000.  He said newspapers printed
overseas for local distribution would also be subject to a hefty fee.  Businesses that did not pay the fee would be
subject to daily fines and up to three months jail time, he added.

Two news organisations – Cayman
News Service and Cayman Net News, the latter which he referred to as Cayman Not
News – were criticised by Mr. Bush.  He
took issue with Cayman Net News for publishing “personal things about one of
our members” which he said were inaccurate, and which were then reprinted in
the United States.  Although he said he didn’t have time to read
Cayman News Service, he said he had been told an anonymous blog commenter had
accused politicians of being paid in the back pockets in relation to the new
hospital project proposed by Dr. Devi Shetty.

Mr. Bush said that media members
who published such things “don’t mean Cayman any good and do not love this country”.

“They are going to pay to operate
in this country,” he said. “If they are going to slander and cause more work
for civil servants, they are going to pay. And I don’t mean $10.”

Information Commissioner Jennifer
Dilbert issued a statement Friday in response to Mr. Bush’s comments on the
Freedom of Information Law.

She acknowledged that a person does
not have to identify themselves when making an FOI request.

“The reasoning behind this is that
a person can request a record and be free from any negative repercussions that
might occur as a result of being identified as the person asking for a record,”
she said. “Many other countries allow anonymous requests and in a country as
small as the Cayman Islands, the ability to
remain anonymous may be indispensable. 
Also, the Law does not permit the public authority to ask for a reason
or rationale behind the request which further ensures that records are released
completely and uncensored.”

Mrs. Dilbert also recognised that a
potential side effect of anonymity was that “frivolous or vexatious requests”
may more easily be made.

“To counteract this, the FOI Law
sets out an exemption under section 9 where a public authority may not be
required to comply with a request if that request is found to be vexatious, or
where it would unreasonably divert the resources of the department to respond
to it.”

She said the exemption had been
used only three times in the first year of operation of the FOI Law, which
indicated that public authorities were not misusing the exemption. 

“In my opinion, and as the Law is
still new to our Islands, the benefits of
anonymity outweigh any inconveniences a public authority may face.”

Mrs. Dilbert reiterated that in
order for the Cayman Islands to benefit from
the FOI regime, responsibility must exist on three levels. 

“I agree with the premier that the
public must exercise discretion and make reasonable requests that serve some
good purpose and not waste the time of public servants,” she said. “They should
also try to become familiar with their rights and the proper procedures so that
they get the responses that they are entitled to.  Second, the press should use the information
that they obtain in a responsible manner. Finally, public authorities, the
government and the civil service must be prepared to operate in an open and
transparent manner, and to fulfil the requirements and meet their obligations
under the FOI Law.”

Opposition Member Alden McLaughlin
said he was worried that Mr. Bush was basically saying he wanted to get rid of
the FOI Law.

“As a member of the administration
that ushered in the atmosphere of openness and transparency, my party and I in
particular would see that as a big step backwards,” he said. “We don’t want to
allow a retreat from this new era.”


Mr. Bush


  1. As the leader of a ‘free’ country you are held accountable for every second of every day. We pay your salary McKeeva and if we the people want to see where you have traveled to we have EVERY right to know. This is not a fascist state and you are not our dictator. If the press wants to question you and your office you need to grow a thicker skin and man up. I hope that the people who voted you in are following this story and see to it that this is your last vacation on behalf of the Caymanian people. (and for those of you who are not following this story the BBC has picked up on it and we have now gone international with our embarassment of a leader)

  2. I mean the man has a point when it comes to unreasonable requests from anyone like Mickey Mouse, which wastes governments time. And he does have a point with the press broadcasting wrong information, especially if that information misrepresents someones character. But Mr. Bush to threaten the media with a hefty fee and jail time because of their blogs and opinionated comments, I think that would be very unwise. They are the last people on earth you want against you! If you censor blogs and comments because they do not suit you, you actually go against the truth from being told and correcting those same erroneous blogs and comments! Please! Desist from attacking freedom of speech and freedom of information! Is anyone in the UDP going to stand up to the Premier or allow him to recklessly impose a law against free speech?

    I am very dissapointed!

  3. Just wondering if he thinks we should pray to get things right? Wasn’t that what was said about the shootings. I’m no atheist but what he’s saying is so insane. Is the man really qualified to do the job?

  4. Bravo to Jennifer Dilbert. The protocol of her position allows her to tell it like it is according to the laws of the Cayman Islands, and this issue needs to be dealt with through a legal rather than an emotional pathway.

  5. 1984?? how about Lord of the flies? politics 101??

    How embarassing that our democratic leader is acting like a bully at school. He is clearly dillusional to the fact that he is an elected official representing the people of the Cayman Islands but he is treating it like a dicatorship.
    We all know about the rumors that he has conspired with other island nations and owns land/investments there with deals done under the table.
    I love how he found a way to get Dan Duguay essentially fired… in my opinion for outting the shamed leader and his government no numberous accounting claims… Dan did his job to well and admitted if he hadn’t he would still have his job.
    Now he want to raise a fist at the media… good luck winning that battle!!! the internet is too large to bring down … the world is bigger than Mickey Mouse!!
    His behavior has really shows his true colors under adversity!!!

Comments are closed.