MLA Eden calls earthquake, coronavirus ‘warnings’ over gay lifestyle

MLA Anthony Eden

Legislator Anthony Eden moved a motion in the Legislative Assembly on Friday to affirm Christian values, an action he described as a direct response to debate over same-sex partnerships.

He advised that natural disasters and disease could be viewed as “warnings” against expanded rights for same-sex couples.

“Mr. Speaker, once the flood gates are opened, what will happen in Cayman? How are we going to stop it? A little population of less than 70,000 built on Christian values. We have been warned over the years,” Eden said on Friday.

He then listed hurricanes Gilbert, Ivan and Paloma as having been such warnings.

“Just earlier this week, Mr. Speaker, an earthquake – the strongest tremor that I’ve known in my 75 years – hit these islands. There’s SARS. AIDS has been there over the years, gradually taking out many people. And now we hear of the coronavirus, recently declared a global emergency by the World Health Organization,” Eden continued.

- Advertisement -

“You’ve seen what’s happened. We better take warning of what’s going on.”

Eden’s private members motion, seconded by MLA Alva Suckoo, seeks “to affirm that expressions of Christian doctrine and scriptures by Christian organisations and individuals is a right protected by the Cayman Islands Constitution Order 2009”.

“I brought this motion in light of the atmosphere of tension and concern in regards to same-sex marriage and what it could lead to in the Cayman Christian and religious community and the values that we have grown to accept over the decades and decades as taught by our families,” Eden said.

“Christian preachers [abroad] are not allowed to refer to the biblical teaching as not supporting same-sex marriage and LGBTQ lifestyles, and it is termed, as we hear so often, Mr. Speaker, ‘hate speech’ and can be prosecuted.

“We’ve seen this propaganda in our own local newspapers when we try to speak up for the values of what we’ve been taught in our lifetime, that what we’re saying is ‘hate speech’. It’s not ‘hate speech’, Mr. Speaker. It comes from the Bible that I read frequently.”

View the full comments here:

- Advertisement -

Support local journalism. Subscribe to the all-access pass for the Cayman Compass.

Subscribe now


  1. In the CI we are a welcoming multi-cultural society and we have religious freedom, including the freedom not to follow any religion if that is our choice. We should not be making laws that impose religious beliefs of one religion on the people as a whole.
    Our government and representatives need to stop wasting time with this issue and instead concentrate on the real problems facing the island such as poor education, increasing crime and environmental issues. These are the things that have a real impact on the lives of the inhabitants.

  2. How does one begin to reply to the overwhelming ignorance and lack of any semblance of common sense that Mr Eden’s statements articulate? In this day and age, with the many social, economic and environmental challenges that we are facing, as a community and on a global scale, can Mr Eden truly think that the solution lies in a simple return to a more,“Godly” lifestyle? Can Mr Eden’s reality be so warped that he truly believes his version of current events? Wow! Talk about buying into propaganda.