Business owner cites immigration ‘nightmare’

No cooks, no chicken

Harrison Bothwell closed his Eastern Avenue jerk stand on Friday. – Photo: Brent Fuller

Harrison Bothwell closed his George Town jerk stand Friday, about two weeks after he first opened it, after work permits for his two cooks expired during an immigration process he described as “a nightmare.”

“Had I known what I was going to be faced with, I would never have undertaken this,” Mr. Bothwell said. “It’s a nightmare.”

Mr. Bothwell, a retired airline pilot who still leads some training courses for Cayman Airways, decided to embark on a post-retirement business venture a few years ago. That venture, the ‘What a Jerk’ jerk stand on Eastern Avenue, opened on Jan. 7 after a significant delay in receiving building occupancy documents. “I guess that’s another story,” he said.

Mr. Bothwell said he received a three-month temporary work permit for one of his cooks through August 2016. The second cook he hired was granted a similar permit to last through September 2016.

It took a bit longer to open the jerk stand than he had first estimated, so Mr. Bothwell said his cook went back to immigration in August, attempting to receive a second three-month permit. According to immigration officials, that was not allowed, and Mr. Bothwell said he was asked to pay for a six-month work permit instead. Cayman Islands Immigration Law requires all non-Caymanian workers to receive a permit before taking up employment in the jurisdiction.

Mr. Bothwell said he received a six-month temporary permit for both cooks, spending a total of $2,240 ($1,120 for each half year permit), which he thought would continue the permits until March and April 2017, respectively.

However, one of the cooks was informed, when he returned to the Immigration Department in December, that his six-month permit had expired as of Dec. 14, 2016 not March 2017.

Mr. Bothwell said his employee tried to argue that the six-month permit should have extended until March 2017. “They said, ‘well, that’s not how it works anymore,’” he said.

Apparently, the six-months for the temporary permit began, in the estimation of immigration officials, at the time the first three-month permit was issued and the six-month extensions – given in August and September – were good only for another three months after that.

Mr. Bothwell said he had already paid $370 for each three-month permit and was being charged again, $2,240, for an additional three months.

“I’m being double-charged for the same permit,” he said Friday.

Mr. Bothwell provided details of email communications sent as late as last week with Immigration Department and Ministry of Home Affairs officials in which his situation was discussed.

According to one email message sent on Jan. 18, Ministry Acting Chief Officer Kathryn Dinspel-Powell wrote: “Mr. Bothwell reports having attempted unsuccessfully to get clarification on this matter … and in the absence of the same, he sent [one of his cooks] home on Monday Jan. 16, 2017, having in the interim attained for him what he was told was a final extension when he attended the [immigration] front counter with [the cook] back in December 2016.

“So, he is without one cook and finds himself in a similar position with [the second cook], whose stamp expires at midnight tomorrow night (19/01/17).

“I am respectfully requesting that the issues surrounding both of these matters be looked into as a matter of urgency, and that in particular, you make personal contact with Mr. Bothwell at [phone number] to discuss what options are available to him under the Law, to enable him to keep [the second cook] on staff beyond midnight tomorrow night, so as to avoid disruption to the business continuity of his operation.”

A reply to the email, from Deputy Chief Immigration Officer Garfield Wong, indicated Mr. Bothwell would receive assistance that day in resolving the issue.

However, Mr. Bothwell said he was told by immigration officials that he would need to pay an additional $370 for each worker, and a $200 fee to speed up the processing of those applications, to obtain another permit extension.

Mr. Bothwell said Friday that he refused to do this and simply closed down the business. One jerk stand cook had already gone home. The other remains in Cayman for now on a visitor’s permit.

Mr. Bothwell said he would reopen the business if he could procure legal permits for his employees. He said he was in talks with the Immigration Department on the matter and hoped the business closure would only be temporary.

“I’ve paid for six [months], and I’m getting three,” he said. “I’m totally discouraged.”

Ms. Dinspel-Powell, Acting Chief Immigration Officer Bruce Smith and Mr. Wong were contacted for additional comment on this story Tuesday morning. No responses had been received by press time.

If you value our service, if you have turned to us in the past few days or weeks for verified, factual updates, if you have watched our live streaming of press conferences or sent an article to a friend... please consider a donation. Quality local journalism was at risk before the coronavirus crisis. It is now deeply threatened. Even a small amount can go a long way to sustaining our mission of informing the public. We need our readers’ financial support now more than ever.



  1. Feeling sad for Mr Bothwell, and my thoughts are that those in authority should give some consideration to Cayman senior citizens, retired and wanting to do a little small business; instead of sitting at home doing nothing beside watching the television and waiting to die. Caymanians in authority do not care about their seniors, and believe that just having a seniors party once a year is sufficient.
    No it is not…….if they are able, help them along by giving them the opportunity to run a small business. Let them be encouraged every day to get out of bed and look forward to still seeing their friends, instead of them just sitting down at the hospital bench and waiting to see one another.
    The Government should have some consideration in not even charging them to obtain a business license when they have gone over the 65 age, and further encouragement by allowing them to pay only half of the fees required for a permit.
    These are the people who built this country when there was only mosquitoes and firewood. So why in their golden years we cannot give them a contented peace of mind.
    This year 2017, One man One Vote, the island divided into constituencies; but can we expect any of the old candidates or new candidates to really consider persons like Mr Bothwell, that he does not have to be frustrated at his age with paying for a business license or full charges for a work permit?. Shame on every one, if the Caymanians who stuck it out through hard times, mosquitoes and brackish water can’t even wake up with a smile every morning.