Woman on trial for firearms violation dies

Carol Ann McNeill-Skorupan

A Madison, Wisconsin woman, who was tried in absentia last week for bringing a firearm and ammunition to Cayman, has died.

Carol Ann McNeill-Skorupan, 68, died “unexpectedly” on April 18, according to an obituary published by a Wisconsin funeral home. No details about her death have yet been released. Her husband did not respond to a message requesting comment.

Her death came a day after a jury in her case was dismissed after it was unable to reach a verdict. On April 18, the day of her death, a new trial was scheduled for September.

McNeill-Skorupan had been arrested in Cayman on Feb. 3, when a .25 calibre handgun and six rounds of ammunition were found in her suitcase at the Owen Roberts International Airport.

She had arrived as a cruise ship passenger, after boarding the ship in Florida. But on the flight from Wisconsin to Florida, one of her bags had been misplaced. She told authorities, after her arrest, that she had asked Delta Air Lines to send the bag, where the firearm was stored, to a friend’s house in Florida. Instead, it was sent to Grand Cayman, the first stop on an 11-day cruise she was on.

McNeill-Skorupan had a concealed weapon permit, but that did not allow her to bring it to the Cayman Islands. She had no licence for the weapon here.

Cayman’s gun laws carry a mandatory minimum 10-year prison sentence for firearm violations, unless there are extenuating circumstances.

McNeill-Skorupan spent three days in jail when she was first arrested, before being released on bail. A judge later gave her permission to travel and she returned home.

Crown counsel Greg Walcolm said he expected the case to be listed for hearing in court Thursday.

“It is the usual course that, upon confirmation of the death of a defendant, a nolle prosequi is entered to discontinue the matter,” Walcolm said in an email.

If you value our service, if you have turned to us in the past few days or weeks for verified, factual updates, if you have watched our live streaming of press conferences or sent an article to a friend... please consider a donation. Quality local journalism was at risk before the coronavirus crisis. It is now deeply threatened. Even a small amount can go a long way to sustaining our mission of informing the public. We need our readers’ financial support now more than ever.



  1. It would be hard to find someone who gets more worked up about violent crime than me.

    But this case, along with others where someone has made a innocent mistake and one bullet is found in their bags while LEAVING our islands, should never have been bought.

    I understand the law should be applied equally and there shouldn’t be one law for locals and one for tourists.

    But let us ask:

    Did they knowingly break the law?
    Did any harm result?

    There is a big difference between some thug swinging a machete around and a lady whose luggage is misdirected by an airline.
    PLEASE let’s focus on the real criminals.

  2. Sometimes the laws one makes really doesn’t serve its purpose. We were so upset with drug gang violence we have ended hurting innocent people that it wasn’t intended to hurt. Old people here and tourists from abroad whose only intentions were completely different. Would it, at last, be said that robberies would be less if one had more then a machete? We had guns before was there much gun crime before? Back in the past would anyone be so brave to cross anyone’s property in the night or day without permission, I think not. I believe we need to think this law with new revisions.

Comments are closed.