Letter: The importance of Emancipation Day

Cayman Compass is the Cayman Islands' most trusted news website. We provide you with the latest breaking news from the Cayman Islands, as well as other parts of the Caribbean.
Cayman Compass is the Cayman Islands' most trusted news website. We provide you with the latest breaking news from the Cayman Islands, as well as other parts of the Caribbean.

I found the article (‘Emancipation Day: ‘a bubbling stew’ of Caribbean heritage’, Cayman Compass, 1 Aug.) informative and edifying and write not so much to add to what was written in the article but rather to lament the absence of, or should I write the deliberate attempt by ignorant elements in Caymanian society to deny the existence of slavery and its ancillary phenomenon in this jurisdiction.

In the mid-1970s, the then political directorate in their attempt to rewrite Caymanian history removed the cultural celebration of Emancipation Day (1 Aug.) from the cultural calendar. Before that time, Emancipation Day in the Cayman Islands was a popular and much celebrated holiday on Grand Cayman with both black people and enlightened whites marking the occasion with dance, camaraderie and revelry.

In Bodden Town, which was both the political as well as the slave capital, the celebration took on a special significance with black folk from all walks of life congregating in jovial mood.

As a youth with ancestral ties dating back to the slave era, I grasped the significance of what black folk sought to preserve in this celebration.

Bodden Towners of my generation and older will recall that Dick Frederick had a standing contract with the authorities for the use of the Bodden Town Town Hall on 1 Aug. The celebration culminated in a dance which really was more like a ball. At this soiree, men and women of colour from all over the island came together to celebrate. The occasion was formal and the quadrille was among the dances performed.

I recall Dick Frederick speaking of another dance which he called the ‘Sir Roger’. As best as I can ascertain, this was some sort of European waltz and, like the quadrille, it was probably the black people’s interpretation of a European dance emanating out of the slave era.

From an early age, I cultivated an interest in and respect for what black Caymanian folk did and, of equal importance, how they felt about the society in which they lived. This was enhanced by the groundings from my mother, whose sense of Pan-African history and culture led me to fathom the duality which is Caymanian society. I later realised that men like Dick Frederick were described by black historians as ‘Royal Africans’.

From the era of the slave ships and beyond, these men and women were entrusted with shepherding, guarding and disseminating the heritage, culture and history of the oppressed and enslaved. It is a fact of some historical importance that the white slave catchers, owners and contractors knew of the existence of such persons and tried their best to prevent them from boarding the slave ships or from working on the plantations.

The cultural history of Bodden town is enriched by the numbers of such persons who played important roles in the preservation of what is increasingly appreciated as our Caymanian heritage.

As always, I am fascinated by what I described in ‘The Cayman Islands in Transition’ as the ‘duality‘ which is Caymanian society. I am intrigued by the number of ‘established Caymanians’ who when questioned as to their ancestry cite Scottish, Irish, Welsh and English (WASP) roots with not so much as a mention of an African connection. Of course we are not African, neither for that matter are we any of the other mentioned ethnicities.

Slavery was an institution predicated upon violence, including sexual violence and force. No society in which slavery existed was exempt from such practices. Taken to its logical conclusion, this suggests that there existed little to no racial purity in slave societies or, in our case, a society with slaves.

Furthermore, European blue bloods abhorred living in the culturally impaired, mosquito-infested colonies. Hence, they sent their attorneys, managers and bookkeepers to attend to their colonial affairs. These persons settled in the colonies and cultivated liaisons with black men and black women. The product of such liaisons are elaborately scaled by Kamau Brathwaite in his seminal work ‘The Development of Creole Society in Jamaica 1770‑1820’.

The Portuguese coined the word for persons of European descent born in the colonies. This word was ‘criollo’, anglicised today as ‘creole’. Today, the term applies equally to all persons (black and white) of established ancestry born in the colonies. Hence my reason for claiming that there is no racial purity among established Caymanians.

Having laid that important foundation, let me now return to what I consider the revisionist attempt to deny history. The records show that slavery existed on Grand Cayman. The record also shows that racism existed (and by my account) still exists in Caymanian society.

If we are honest with ourselves, we should try to exorcise these old ghosts before the situation becomes chronic. Those who continue in the present vein, leave themselves open to that most frightening of situations as mentioned by the philosopher George Santayana – “Those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it.”

I live with the hope that the Emancipation Day Holiday (1 Aug.) will one day return to the Caymanian cultural ca lendar and that Long Celia will take her rightful place among the pantheon of National Heroes of these islands.

J.A. Roy Bodden

Support local journalism. Subscribe to the all-access pass for the Cayman Compass.

Subscribe now