Court orders retrial in death of Brian Rankine Carter

William McLaughlin Martinez wins appeal against murder conviction


Cayman Islands Court of Appeal has ordered a retrial for William McLaughlin
Martinez, who was convicted by a jury in July 2009 for the murder of Brian

body of the deceased, who was 20 years old, was found in a vacant lot along
McField Lane in George Town in the early hours of 17 May 2008.

Mark Tomassi, assisted by attorney Nick Dixey, argued the appeal on Tuesday
morning and the court agreed with his first ground — that the jury had been
misdirected by the trial judge.

misdirection came in response to a question from the jury after they had been
sent out to begin deliberations.

concerned the evidence of the Crown’s main witness, Jason Hinds, 27 at the
time. The question was, “When attempting to reach a verdict can we discount
Hinds’ testimony and reach a verdict based on forensic evidence?”

General Cheryll Richards argued that the judge’s answer was appropriate in the
context of all he had said earlier.

who pleaded guilty in 2008 to being an accessory after the fact to the murder,
was sentenced to three and a half years imprisonment.

senior prison official confirmed to the Caymanian Compass that Hinds was no
longer in custody, having been picked up be Immigration officers and deported.
It was not immediately ascertained when this occurred.

Martinez, 33, is to return to Grand Court for a trial date to be set.

president Sir John Chadwick announced the decision after conferring with
Justices Elliott Mottley and Abdullah Conteh.

said full reasons would be put into writing.
The only sentence in Cayman for murder is life imprisonment.


A photo from the May 2008 scene where Brian Rankine Carter met his end just hours before.
Photo: File