EDITORIAL – Keeping quiet on animal cruelty and crime

“This dog was basically chained to a tree and starved to death. If the police hadn’t been called to the house for a search warrant, the other dog would probably have died too.

“This is the worst case of neglect I have seen in the Cayman Islands and it should be brought to the courts and prosecuted.”

— Jason Jairam, shelter manager, Cayman Islands Humane Society

Police officers raided a home in Prospect on Friday, looking for a criminal suspect. In addition to their man, they found a dog — chained to a tree, sun-beaten and starving, next to another dog that had not survived the same conditions.

The incident should serve as Cayman’s “Michael Vick moment” (an allusion to the former NFL star’s conviction for dogfighting); a badly needed wake-up call to the country of the prevalence of barbaric animal cruelty, and, furthermore, that the casual torture of dogs is just one category of innocent suffering that we should not allow to continue to occur.

The case of “Lennie” (the puppy who lived) and his unnamed companion (who did not) illustrates three important points about the broader nature of crime in Cayman.

First, the connection between animal cruelty and criminality in general: The dog was discovered at a home that was harboring a fugitive from justice. Scientific studies have shown a correlation between disregard for animal life (or laws governing the treatment of animals) and disrespect for human life.

Second, the culture of silence and fear: As Mr. Jairam said, the neighbors surely would have seen the two dogs chained to the tree, starving for days or weeks, and yet nobody called to report the cruelty or otherwise did anything about it. Similarly, time and time again, when violent crimes occur in full view of multiple bystanders, police and prosecutors are consistently unable to produce witnesses who care enough, or are brave enough, to testify in court.

Third, the non-enforcement of our country’s laws: Mr. Jairam said in his 10 years with the Humane Society, “I have seen all kinds of abuse, but I have never seen or heard of anyone being prosecuted.” In a letter that appears elsewhere on this page, 21-year Cayman resident Bill Stevenson writes that he’s not aware of one arrest or prosecution for animal cruelty despite its occurrence being “common knowledge.” Likewise, we at the Compass have investigated the issue and have not been able to discover one instance of the successful prosecution of offenses against the Animals Law.

The second and third points are inextricably linked. There is a huge price to pay for silence in the presence of wrongdoing. At minimum, it’s the perpetuation of the misconduct. In Cayman, silence is a plague — among society, the business community and even our leadership — on issues ranging from domestic violence, to shameful neglect of the elderly, to mistreatment of domestic workers, to corruption and dysfunction in government.

Dogs, other animals, and also many humans who are suffering do not have the ability or capacity to speak up for themselves. Citizens who do have a voice have an obligation not just to speak up when they see something heinous, but to speak out publicly — and not to stop until something has been done about it.

If you value our service, if you have turned to us in the past few days or weeks for verified, factual updates, if you have watched our live streaming of press conferences or sent an article to a friend... please consider a donation. Quality local journalism was at risk before the coronavirus crisis. It is now deeply threatened. Even a small amount can go a long way to sustaining our mission of informing the public. We need our readers’ financial support now more than ever.



  1. I am so sickened by the cruelty, ignorance, neglect by Cayman residents and the same for the police and legislators turning their heads and not dealing with cruelty to animals, that I cannot speak on this subject at this time.

  2. Keeping quiet on animal cruelty and crime . How do we expect to live in a civilize world when we see a dog been tied up and punished to death , and hide and protect criminals with no consequences .
    What is this teaching the kids / next-generation ? Or do we want to continue to live in a uncivilized country and
    Government sitting down and being just like the enablers .

  3. Another case when everybody knew and nothing was done. This time not just by neighbors and acquaintances. But by those who had a duty to protect.

    21-year-old Nichelle Anna-Kay Thomas .
    (quotes from the Compass article March 2, 2016)
    -The complaint had been made by a next-door neighbor.
    -Royal Cayman Islands Police Service received five reports of incidents involving the couple.
    -That’s five failed opportunities to save Ms. Thomas’s life.
    -No charges were ever levied. No arrests were ever made. No forms were ever filed with the police Central Referral Unit.
    -Police Constable Owen Santo Jr.: He said he did not fill out a domestic violence report because Ms. Thomas did not show any signs of fearing for her safety.
    -Police Constable VonDante Leslie : The officer stated that he was aware it was procedure to fill out a domestic incident form…but….. We did not prepare a referral on this occasion.

    FIVE!!!!! failed opportunities to save Ms. Thomas’s life. Was there an investigation WHY forms were ever filed with the police Central Referral Unit?

  4. Can we please be honest here for a second?

    How many people would report their neighbour for animal cruelty if they suspect that their neighbor is involved in criminal activity and is likely to be someone that has access to illegal firearms?

    While the police now have bullet proof vests, tasers and guns to protect themselves from the new face of crime in the Cayman Islands what exactly do the ordinary citizens have that they can use to protect themselves? The citizens of this country are as much if not more on the front lines of the fight against crime in this country but have no additional means to protect themselves and their families.

  5. After volunteering for a bit at the humane society, we fell in love and adopted a mix. After bringing her to the DoE (where they tried to get us to surrender her), we were told she wouldn’t be allowed back on island because she might have been mixed with an aggressive breed. But after seeing how many poisonings, purposeful starvations, and lack of enforcement continues to plague the island–I’m not sure I’d want to bring my dog back on Island.

    The only enforcement I’ve seen: https://www.caymancompass.com/2015/07/24/stray-dogs-targeted-after-attack-on-governor-kilpatrick/